Skip to main content
Ask a Question
Practice Area

Appraisal Review

Independent evaluation of whether an appraisal defines the assignment correctly and supports its methodology, analysis, and conclusions.

property plans, an aerial image and notes on an unoccupied worktable.
The Review Assignment

Evaluate the work, not the appraiser

An independent appraisal review evaluates whether the work is credible for its intended use. It may address the property interest, effective date, scope of work, market evidence, highest and best use, appraisal methods, assumptions and the support for the conclusion.

Review or New Appraisal?

First determine what needs to be answered

A review evaluates an existing appraisal. It may include a reviewer’s own value opinion when required by the assignment, but obtaining another appraisal is a different service. Bailey Valuation helps identify the appropriate role and scope.

When an Independent Review May Help

Common situations involving disputed appraisals

Conflicting Appraisal OpinionsTwo reports conclude materially different values. A review of one or both can identify where their underlying evidence, assumptions and reasoning differ.
Your Own Expert’s AppraisalAn independent review may identify weaknesses before counsel relies on a report in negotiations, mediation or trial.
An Opposing AppraisalReview findings may help counsel identify disputed conclusions for examination, settlement discussions or presentation of expert evidence.
Professional Standards & LiabilityAssignments may examine compliance with applicable standards, report credibility and appraisal work involved in alleged errors or omissions.

Review findings may support or challenge the appraisal under examination; the purpose is not to produce a predetermined criticism.

Professional Review

The review has its own assignment requirements

The reviewer’s client, intended use, scope of work and assignment conditions may differ from those of the original appraisal. An appropriate review considers the standards and other requirements applicable to the work being reviewed.